Home > General, News > Homework Assignment

Homework Assignment

Yesterday, Rush Limbaugh gave his listeners a homework assignment. Yes, the education never ends at the Limbaugh Institute of Conservative Studies. The assignment is to share his recent discussion on privileges and rights we have as citizens of the United States. So, I do not have a large circle of friends, so why not share it here.

Whether you agree or disagree with Rush, it is a good read on his website.  It should be posted for a couple weeks, but I have posted the meat of this great discussion on it.  Read further.

BEGIN TRANSCRIPT

RUSH: Well, you know what I think is happening here with your argument, I know exactly what you’re trying to say, but my philosophy on all this is that we have accepted too many premises of the left in all of these social problems that we have and we want to massage their basic solution just enough that we can call it ours. And we might want to throw in, as you are doing, a little touch of capitalism or free market to it, but it basically is going to stay a socialized system. Going back to your business about health care is not a right. No less than Mr. Buckley said that to me. He has said it to a number of people, “Health care isn’t a right, it is a privilege.” Now, what are we supposed to do? Are we supposed to sacrifice language, are we supposed to give up on definite concepts in order win votes and win elections? It’s like I had a column from the American Spectator the other day from a guy that lives in Nebraska, very big on ethanol. We’re not supposed to criticize ethanol. We’re not supposed to criticize this stuff because we’ll not get votes. So we’re supposed to go along with something that doesn’t work, is more expensive.

We just had a story yesterday that if these ethanol tankers driving around happen to have an accident and they blow up, the foam to put out an ethanol fire is 30% more expensive than the foam required to put out a gasoline fire and communities are having to ramp up for this. The cost of corn is going through the roof. The cost of wheat’s going up. A bagel on Long Island a year ago that was 60 cents is now a buck, all of this because of a hoax. And yet to keep the farm vote we’re supposed to not criticize something that doesn’t work. A friend of mine in a state on the East Coast sent me a note. This is yesterday: “I heard a rather liberal GOP political consultant here in Raleigh say today that health care is too complicated to be a deciding issue in the elections; it can’t be summarized in 30 seconds, it’s just too hard.” So we’re not even supposed to talk about it, don’t even go there. Liberal Republican consultants, don’t even talk about health care, it’s a losing issue, just as you are saying, Tony. I don’t accept that it’s a losing issue, and I don’t accept that we have to accept things about it, like it’s a right or it is too complicated.

In less than 30 seconds, I can explain health care in a nutshell. No employer, no insurance company, no politician or government bureaucrat knows better than you about your family’s health needs. You should have the right to purchase health care and health insurance as you see fit without governmental restrictions or penalties, and you should not be of the mind that your neighbors have to buy it for you. Less than 30 seconds I’ve just explained the concept of fixing health care. It is not complicated. It is very simple. We get liberalism out of it; we get socialism out of it; we disabuse people of the notion that liberals have impressed them with that it is a right. I’m starting to hear a lot of this, “We can’t say that we’re going to lose the election. We can’t say that. We can’t say his middle name. We can’t call him a liberal. We can’t be critical of health care as a right.” Pretty soon our own people are going to succeed in shutting enough of us up that liberalism is going to win without having to say a damn thing.

BREAK TRANSCRIPT

RUSH: All right. I know this is probably going to confound some of you who think, or wish, “Just drop this,” or maybe you hope that I will just drop this and stop being provocative on this health care stuff because you think it’s a losing issue. It’s not who I am. I am hell-bent on as many people as possible understanding the truth, the greatness of this country, how it works and how it is going to be sustained. Health care is not a right, it is a privilege. It’s a choice. However, the accumulation of wealth, the accumulation of wealth is a right. That is, you have a right to freely earn an income and dispose of it as you wish: purchase food, purchase shelter, if you want to purchase health care, whatever else. And that right comes from God as enunciated in the Declaration of Independence. You know how it goes. You know the drill, the pursuit of life, liberty, pursuit of happiness. The right to accumulate wealth exists for all of us, but health care is an expenditure, therefore it is not a right. Besides that, folks, we have Medicaid for the poor. We have the S-CHIP program for poor children and, if the Democrats get their way, children up to 25 who come from wealthy families. We have Medicare for seasoned citizens.

What we also have in this country are some people who don’t want to use their own assets to pay for their own health care. They want someone else to do it. And that brings in a very happy and compliant Democrat Party. It is a matter of individual priorities. Let me say it to you as Mr. Buckley might have said it. Moral obligations, should one choose to assume moral obligations, are actually higher on the list of things than rights. That’s why we set up systems to take care of the indigent, because we are a moral people. It is why we have Medicare; it is why we have Medicaid; it is why we have S-CHIP. At least it’s why we started them. It’s why good people support them. We can get into an argument here of whether these programs are more of the same liberal drivel to create as many dependents as possible, but I think we are a compassionate country, and we are a country that understands our moral obligations to people who can’t provide for themselves because of certain things, and those people nobody will argue with, being taken care of and helped. That is precisely why we set up systems to take care of the indigent. It is why we take care of our neighbors. It is why we have our churches engage in the various community actions that they do and, not to mention, there’s all kinds of other community organizations that exist for the express purpose of bringing things to poor, indigent people that they don’t have and can’t have on their own.

This is a country of high moral obligation, and we meet those moral obligations at all times. That is why, because we have such a moral obligation, and because we are such a compassionate people, and because we are such a generous people, this is why we try to lower costs and increase competition so that more people can be taken care of well, so that people are not left to fall through the cracks. Now, this doesn’t mean that any of this is a right. It is our moral obligation as a society that has us take care of people who otherwise could not afford this. But what has happened is that people who very well could afford it, just as they could afford a plasma TV or a car or what have you, can afford health care and choose not to, they choose in fact for others, their neighbors, fellow citizens, to pay for it, precisely because they have been led to believe that it is their right to have health care. And I would submit to you that the whole notion of having your neighbor pay for what your responsibilities are can be very addictive, once it starts. In a real sense, rights are universal and cannot be created once we have enough wealth to have some people want something else. Rights are the lowest claim and therefore command universal respect.

We have to bring back the meaning of words. Privileges and moral obligations are higher than basic human rights, not dragged around by them. That is something that Mr. Buckley would say to you. Privileges and more obligations are higher than basic human rights. They’re not dragged around by them. Human rights do not dictate moral obligations; it’s just the exact opposite. Moral obligations manifest themselves in the form of human rights, and so when our moral obligations and our morality is being torn down and the whole concept of doing things for the right reason becomes doing things for the wrong reason, and when people opt out of their own personal responsibility to acquire that which they want with their own assets and shove that on all the rest of us, then we’re in trouble, and that’s where we are in health care, precisely because we have allowed enough people to believe that health care is their right, not their responsibility.

If this is something I shouldn’t discuss because it’s only going to inflame people and make them hate Republicans and think that we’re cold-hearted and cruel, so be it. I’ll be glad to talk to any of them and explain how the real compassion, the real big-heartedness exists on our side using the very same argument about moral obligations and the evidence of how we do in this country, without complaint, take care of those who cannot help themselves, and we are eager to do it, because we are a compassionate people. But we also know that no one, no society can sustain itself if everybody in the society is depending on everybody else to pay what they want, or buy what they want. So we’re not supposed to use Obama’s middle name; we’re not supposed to call him a liberal; we are not supposed to talk about health care in the campaign, according to Republican consultants, it’s too complicated, and we’re not supposed to say that health care is not a right. Pretty soon, as I say, we’re not going to be able to say anything, and we won’t have to, and the Democrats won’t have to, either, because we will have effectively shut ourselves up.

END TRANSCRIPT

Advertisements
Categories: General, News Tags: , , , ,
  1. No comments yet.
  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: